Is J.D. Vance Right About Europe? J D Vance's Europe: Populism, Elites, and the EU's Reach Study Guide: "Is J.D. Vance Right about Europe?" by Christopher Caldwell This study guide is designed to review your understanding of Christopher Caldwell's article "Is J.D. Vance Right about Europe?" published in Imprimis. It covers key arguments, concepts, and examples presented in the text. I. Summary of Key Arguments and Concepts A. J.D. Vance's Core Critique of Europe: Fundamental Values at Risk: Vance argues that Europe is retreating from core values like free speech and democracy. Immigration as a Barometer: He views the ongoing increase in immigration despite voter preference for less as a sign of hostility to democracy. Populism vs. Elites: Europe, like the U.S., is split between "populists" (anti-establishment) and "elites" (pro-establishment). The key difference is the greater difficulty populists face in gaining power in Europe. ...