Fireworks: Republican Congressman vs. MSNBC on Immigration

Idaho Congressman Raul Labrador appeared on MSNBC this morning and put on a clinic in effective messaging. He demonstrated how to disagree without being disagreeable, how to reject false premises, and how to turn the tables against critics. Despite being outnumbered four-to-one, a fairly typical liberal-to-conservative ratio on the non-news network, Labrador thrived (the meat of the exchange begins at the three-minute mark):

Host Alex Wagner asks Labrador about the perceived "narrative" of Republican obstructionism on the issue; Labrador flips her challenge on its head by highlighting Chuck Schumer's vow of intransigence. Wagner counters that the Senate bill passed on a bipartisan basis; Labrador points out that only a small minority of the Senate Republican conference voted for it. While periodically circling back to his support for meaningful reform, the Congressman also cites the CBO's estimate that the Senate bill would at best curtail the inflow of illegal immigrants by half, failing to sufficiently resolve the underlying problem. He also underscores the public's clear demand for meaningfulborder security as a prerequisite for other reforms -- a view shared by most American Hispanics, according to a recent survey. "I don't want to be here in ten years debating this issue again," he concludes. Labrador's strongest answers come toward the end of the discussion, when he adroitly delineates between respectful outreach and pandering. He also says that he's not especially interested in MSNBC's "helpful" advice to the Republican Party -- a point that's well taken.

Regular readers will recall that I've been a fan of Rep. Labrador's for some time. His proposed immigration overhaul proposal is sensible and realistic (I might consider broadening its 'path to citizenship' provisions, as one small quibble), and ought to serve as the basis for any plan the House majority advances. Critically, it reverses the Senate bill's flawed sequencing, which begins mass legalization before any border enforcement enhancements are put in place. As House Republicans huddle to chart a path forward on this issue, they'd be wise to make Labrador -- a former immigration attorney -- a key point man on policy, and a prominent spokesman for their effort. The sophomore from Idaho proved his value on both fronts in decidedly hostile territory today. I'll leave you with a small note to Alex Wagner: For future reference, the US-Mexico border is not "tens of thousands of miles" long.

Fireworks: Republican Congressman vs. MSNBC on Immigration
http://townhall.com/tipsheet/guybenson/2013/07/10/fireworks-republican-congressman-vs-msnbc-on-immigration-n1637951

John Hames

Superbowl anti-gun ad, hope it backfires on them

PAT DOLLARD YOUNG AMERICANS 11 Hours Ago Bloomberg to Air Gun Control Ad During Superbowl Feb 2, 2013Toro520 Via The Associated Press: NEW YORK (Associated Press) – A gun control group founded by New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg is airing a Super Bowl advertisement calling for background checks. The 30-second spot by Mayors Against Illegal Guns will air in the Washington area during the game between the Baltimore Ravens and San Francisco 49ers. The ad calls on lawmakers to pass rules requiring background checks on guns. It is narrated by children, with “America the Beautiful” playing in the background. It includes decades-old footage of National Rifle Association Executive Vice President Wayne LaPierre saying the gun lobby group approves of the checks. LaPierre recently testified before the Senate Judiciary Committee that the NRA no longer supports background checks for all gun sales. A Bloomsberg spokesman would say only that the ad cost in the six-figure range....

PM Briefing: Rolling Stone Editor Torches His Liberal Colleagues: ‘The American Left Has Lost Its Mind’

Rolling Stone Editor Torches His Liberal Colleagues: ‘The American Left Has Lost Its Mind’ Rolling Stone Editor Torches His Liberal Colleagues: ‘The American Left Has Lost Its Mind’ READ STORY ADVERTISEMENT South Philly Men Teach Leftwing Scum That Bothering Neighborhoods Where They Aren’t Welcome Is a Dumb Move READ STORY Fulton County DA Tells CNN He’s Considering Murder Charges Against Atlanta PD Officer READ STORY Jonathan Pie Might Not Be A Household Name In America, But His Take On Social Unrest Proves He Should Be READ STORY ...

Your NRA-ILA Daily Alert

Catch up with the daily NRA-ILA Alert! view the web version of this email DAILY ALERT FOR Wednesday, September 2, 2020 THE WASHINGTON FREE BEACON August Shatters Another Gun Sales Record August 2020 saw more gun sales than any other August on record as Americans continue to rush to gun stores at a record pace. A Washington Free Beacon analysis of FBI data released on Tuesday found a 57 percent increase in sales compared to August 2019. There were at least 1.6 million sales in August 2020. BREITBART Alleged Armed Robber Shot Dead by Car Wash Customer An alleged armed robber in Roseville, Michigan, was shot dead by a car wash customer around 7 p.m. on Tuesday night. FOX NEWS Wi...

Search This Blog